UBS On-Air: Paul Donovan Daily Audio 'Paying for government'
The desk interprets recent policy statements from French Prime Minister Lecornu as indicative of a broader global trend towards enhanced fiscal responsibility, which aligns with rising discussions around wealth taxation in light of extensive fiscal deficits. Per the full note from UBS, the French budget deficit goal is set at 4.7% of GDP, with no drastic changes to public holidays or a general wealth tax anticipated. This context is crucial as it reflects how governments might mobilize wealth under tighter fiscal conditions while trying to avoid politically sensitive tax increases, signaling potentially smoother monetary strategies and confidence from the markets in the face of stagnant public finance reforms.
What the desk is arguing
The European macro landscape is being shaped by the policy decisions and fiscal targets set forth by political leaders, particularly in France. The current 4.7% GDP deficit target proposed by Prime Minister Lecornu suggests a careful navigation of fiscal policy, emphasizing sustainability over immediate tax reform. Per the full note from UBS, the avoidance of sweeping wealth taxes indicates a preference for maintaining stability while managing public finances responsibly.
Moreover, the broader implications of these discussions signal a likely global shift towards wealth mobilization through less conventional means, driven by the ongoing Great Wealth Transfer. This backdrop provides a nuanced understanding of how governmental actions could influence market perceptions and reactions.
Where it sits in our coverage
Our estimates currently position the EUR/USD at a consensus target of 1.075, with a range observed between 1.04 and 1.12. Notable firms contributing to the consensus include: - jpmorgan with a target of 1.10 for March 2026 - bofa with a lower estimate of 1.04 for the same tenor
This perspective aligns closely with jpmorgan's assessment, while diverging from bofa's more cautious stance, indicating there's room for upward movements in the euro given the current fiscal rhetoric, though caution remains prudent as the lower bound indicates significant market skepticism.
How other firms see it
Aligning firms such as jpmorgan anticipate a strengthening euro against the backdrop of fiscal policy stability in major Eurozone economies. Contrarily, bofa projects a more conservative outlook based on potential economic headwinds, creating a contrast in market positioning.
As the discussions around wealth taxation evolve, the interaction between French fiscal policies and broader European economic indicators will likely be crucial in the EUR/USD trajectory, especially as the European Central Bank responds to inflation drivers from member states such as Spain.
What the calendar says
With no high-impact events scheduled in the upcoming weeks, the focus remains on existing fiscal policy frameworks and market sentiment, paving the way for traders to monitor ongoing developments closely without immediate data catalysts influencing the currency pair.
How firms align with this view
Aligned with the desk view
Contrary positioning
Key takeaways
- 01French fiscal policy reflects a global trend towards wealth mobilization without implementing drastic tax reforms.
- 02The 4.7% GDP deficit target indicates caution and responsibility in managing public finances.
- 03Market perceptions are being shaped by political rhetoric surrounding fiscal responsibilities and potential rolling out of wealth taxation.
- 04Investment strategies should consider potential volatility as European fiscal discussions evolve.
Market implications
Traders should closely watch the EUR/USD level around 1.075, as fiscal narratives surrounding wealth transfer and tax justice could lead to volatility in trading sentiment. Additionally, any shifts in ECB policy in response to inflation indicators from the Eurozone will be key in assessing market movements.
Risks to this view
The main risks to this view arise from potential political instability in France or unforeseen shifts in ECB policy that could overturn current fiscal expectations. Any drastic fiscal changes or unanticipated economic data releases could also force a reevaluation of the current macroeconomic outlook.
Good morning, this is Paul Donovan, Chief Economist at GBS Global Wealth Management. It's 7 o'clock in the morning London time on Monday the 29th of September. The current French Prime Minister, Le Corneau, set out a series of policy proposals that they would like to implement if they were to stay in power.
The budget deficit aspiration is more or less intact at 4.7% of GDP. There will be no cancelling of public holidays and no return of a generic wealth tax. However, there was a reference to tax justice.
This is something that is likely to become a global trend. With the Great Wealth Transfer underway and taking place against a backdrop of larger fiscal deficits, governments are unlikely to ignore the issue of wealth. A general wealth tax is, however, normally quite expensive to collect and difficult to assess.
Instead, other means of mobilising wealth are likely to be put into place. Spain starts the European inflation process with the release of September preliminary consumer price data. This is expected to show an increase, although it is worth noting that not many economists actually forecast Spanish inflation, and the range of estimates of those that do is quite wide.
It's not quite anything goes, but it does mean that it would be unwise to suggest that there is a clear picture of what the market is expecting today. It's not likely to change the ECB's decision making anyway, making whatever number comes in at an unlikely market mover. US President Trump is to meet with Democrat legislators over the impending US government shutdown.
Markets are not too concerned, not because a shutdown is improbable. Some kind of shutdown now does seem quite likely. Rather, markets have become used to these periodic demonstrations of political machismo and tend to regard this as political theatre for an audience that is primarily inside the Washington beltway.
The macroeconomic consequences tend to be reversed quite quickly, always assuming that federal workers' back pay is paid back and jobs are reinstated. There are consequences for those who depend on government services, but the disruption is not likely to be as great as the economic consequences of the doge cuts earlier this year. Those were more random in nature and led to services being unavailable for unpredictably long periods of time.
We get the Dallas Fed manufacturing sentiment poll today. As ever, the numbers are too partisan to be really useful, but the comment section is worth looking at for entertainment. To actually bother to add a comment to a sentiment survey, one has to be really wound up about things, and so the comments are far more for entertainment value than serving as an actual representation of the economy.
Sources & References
How we cover this story