UBS On-Air: Paul Donovan Daily Audio 'The UFP – Unsustainable Fiscal Position'
The desk interprets UBS Chief Economist Paul Donovan's comments on the U.S. fiscal position as a critical indicator of potential market complacency towards legislative gridlock. Per the full note, the U.S. Senate's passage of a bill underscoring a long-standing unsustainable fiscal situation has elicited mixed responses, particularly among fiscal conservatives in the House. The prevailing sentiment suggests that while markets are aware of the inherent fiscal challenges, they remain largely indifferent for the time being, which may leave them vulnerable should sentiment shift. Given the context of trade tensions, particularly threats from President Trump regarding taxes on Japanese imports, the potential for a negative market reaction could become a significant factor in determining the stability of the USD. Notably, the U.S. price shifts in Japanese auto exports indicate that the expectations of U.S. consumers' responses to these tariffs are multifaceted and may dampen market response to fiscal issues in the short term.
What the desk is arguing
The desk argues that the focus on unsustainable fiscal policy in the U.S. is indicative of deeper underlying tensions within economic policy. Per the full note, this disconnect between political maneuvering and market reaction could create a volatile environment if trade tensions escalate further.
The commentary highlights the difficulty in quantifying the fiscal redistribution from lower-income to higher-income households, suggesting that this may complicate future economic models and market expectations. The potential for a trade conflict, particularly with Japan regarding tariffs, adds another layer of uncertainty that could ultimately sway market sentiment.
Where it sits in our coverage
Our consensus target for USD/JPY is 1.075, with a range suggesting volatility around 1.04 to 1.12. Prominent firms like jpmorgan are aligned with this target, forecasting 1.10 for March 2026, while bofa remains contrary at a target of 1.04 for the same tenor.
This view aligns with a heavier emphasis on fiscal and trade policy dynamics, indicating that jpmorgan's outlook captures a more optimistic scenario relative to the broader consensus, while bofa provides a bearish counterpoint that suggests greater risks ahead.
How other firms see it
Among aligned firms, jpmorgan and dbs share a similar optimistic outlook on the USD, suggesting a strengthening trend against the JPY through various timelines. Conversely, bofa stands as a contrary firm, asserting a more cautious stance that underscores potential downsides based on fiscal uncertainty.
Of note, the USD/JPY trajectory aligns closely with shifts in U.S. trade policy and could be influenced by upcoming statements from the Federal Reserve regarding monetary policy shifts.
How firms align with this view
Aligned with the desk view
Contrary positioning
Key takeaways
- 01The U.S. fiscal position remains a contentious issue in political and market realms.
- 02Trade tensions, particularly with Japan, could heighten market volatility.
- 03Market complacency may leave currencies vulnerable to policy shifts or unexpected economic data.
- 04Consensus targets reflect a cautious outlook amid prevailing uncertainties.
Market implications
Watch for fluctuations in USD/JPY, particularly around the 1.075 level, as trade discussions and fiscal policies unfold. Any unexpected escalation in trade tensions, specifically regarding tariffs, could provoke a sharper market response.
Risks to this view
The primary risk to this outlook would be a significant reversal in Congressional support for fiscal measures, particularly if House Republicans fail to align on budget proposals. Additionally, escalated trade disputes, especially with significant players like Japan, could undermine dollar stability and lead to adverse movements against the JPY.
Good morning, this is Paul Donovan, Chief Economist at UBS Global Wealth Management. It's 7 o'clock in the morning London time on Wednesday the 2nd of July. The US Senate passed a bill to enshrine the unsustainability of the US fiscal position into law.
The bill now goes back to the House of Representatives, where the unsustainable nature of the unsustainable fiscal position seems to be causing some problems. The House version of the budget passed with just one vote, and fiscal conservatives are threatening not to support the Senate measure, although Republican leadership in the House seems confident that something will pass. The markets are, if not indifferent, not significantly focused on this.
The unsustainable fiscal position is known about. The full consequences of the redistribution from lower income to higher income households is hard to model and will only emerge over time. The details that get politicians so excited are unlikely to change what markets are pricing in for the short term.
Trade is proving a little more exciting for financial markets, with the lack of trade deals and the self-imposed deadline for increasing the tax burden on US consumers rapidly approaching. Yesterday US President Trump threatened to increase taxes on US consumers who buy products from Japan. This is interesting, as Japan is pretty much the only country where exporters have absorbed some of the US tax increase.
Finished Japanese car export prices to the states have defied pre-tax trends and fallen to offset some, though not all, of the US tax. This has not happened in other sectors in Japan, including auto parts. Markets are not generally inclined to believe that Trump will follow through on tax threats, but Trump does have a long history of antagonism towards Japan over tariffs dating back to the 1980s.
Meanwhile, the EU seems intent on blocking UK membership of the Pan-Euro-Mediterranean Convention, a trade bloc that no one has heard of, but membership of which would make post-Brexit trade somewhat easier. It might just be political posturing, but it is a step back from recent moves towards greater trade cooperation between the UK and EU. There's some labour market data today.
The US ADP payrolls do not often correlate that closely to official payrolls. It's an interesting question as to whether official US payrolls correlate that closely to the US labour market reality these days either. Nevertheless, labour data, whatever its reliability, is going to play an important part in Federal Reserve decision-making.
Yesterday's US job openings data, one of the least reliable statistics published by the US government, showed a labour market generally in line with long-term trends but with some clear anomalies in the manufacturing sector, especially durable goods manufacturing. That is, of course, the area most affected by trade taxes. From Europe, there is the official unemployment rate issued from the euro area.
Sources & References
How we cover this story