UBS On-Air: Paul Donovan Daily Audio 'Taxing US consumers, cutting China’s taxes'
The desk interprets the recent commentary by Paul Donovan of UBS as a signal that China may pivot to aggressive fiscal measures to boost domestic consumption in reaction to potential tariffs from the incoming Trump administration. Per the full note, Donovan emphasizes that monetary tools alone are insufficient to stimulate consumer spending due to current socio-economic challenges like high youth unemployment and property market declines. China’s policymakers might view this moment as an opportunity to recalibrate tax policies aimed at stimulating local consumption, particularly as November trade data showed weaker-than-expected exports and imports from China amidst shifting consumption patterns in developed economies.
What the desk is arguing
The desk posits that China is likely to implement substantial fiscal stimulus in response to ongoing external pressures, particularly those from the US. As noted by UBS, the push for stimulus aligns with the current economic sentiments, indicating a strong link between U.S. policy changes and Chinese fiscal strategy.
Supporting this perspective, the commentary highlights that the youth unemployment rate remains high, leading to consumer reluctance, a situation that necessitates robust fiscal intervention rather than mere monetary adjustments. This is seen as especially vital as China's trade data from November fell short of expectations, underscoring the fragility of the economy amidst changing consumer preferences.
Where it sits in our coverage
Our consensus target for this economic outlook is pegged at 1.075, with a range of 1.04 to 1.12. Notably, jpmorgan aligns with this outlook, setting a target of 1.10 for March 2026, while bofa takes a contrary stance, anticipating a lower target of 1.04.
This viewpoint aligns closely with the consensus, reflecting marginal shifts in the market's sentiment amidst ongoing discussions around tariffs and fiscal responses. The current desk view hovers at the upper bounds of the predicted range, indicating a positive outlook on the potential for fiscal stimulus in China.
How other firms see it
The broader market sentiment appears mixed; aligned firms like jpmorgan anticipate a bullish view driven by Chinese stimulus, while contrary firms such as bofa maintain a cautious stance reflecting potential downsides from international trade tensions.
In this context, traders should watch related indicators such as the USD/CNH pair and the performance of Chinese equities as they could be significantly influenced by fiscal decisions and shifts in consumer confidence. The interplay between these pairs can provide additional insights into market direction in response to policy changes.
How firms align with this view
Aligned with the desk view
Contrary positioning
Key takeaways
- 01China may soon announce significant fiscal stimulus measures.
- 02Continued consumer reluctance in China emphasizes the need for targeted government intervention.
- 03US-China tariff discussions could catalyze domestic reforms in China's economic policy.
- 04Market reactions to stimulus announcements should be closely monitored.
Market implications
Monitor the USD/CNH exchange rate closely as it may react sharply to any announcements regarding fiscal stimulus from China. Additionally, pay attention to trade flows and sentiment in Chinese equities for secondary effects stemming from shifts in consumption patterns.
Risks to this view
The primary risk to this outlook arises if the Trump administration proceeds with tariffs that spark retaliatory measures from China. Such actions could undermine the expected positive impact of fiscal stimulus and further dampen consumer confidence within China, potentially exacerbating the current economic challenges.
Good morning, this is Paul Donovan, Chief Economist at GBS Global Wealth Management. It's seven o'clock in the morning London time on Tuesday the 10th of December. China's Politburo hinted strongly at more aggressive fiscal and monetary stimulus in an announcement yesterday.
This has reignited hopes, which come and go, about a proper attempt to help boost China's domestic consumption. The focus should be on fiscal policy. Rate cuts are all very nice, but the cost of credit is not what is holding back China's consumers.
With widespread youth unemployment, negative wealth effects from real estate and limited government assistance, consumers are afraid about the future. That requires fiscal stimulus to make meaningful differences, and it needs to be properly and convincingly applied. That should then boost China's domestic consumption.
In terms of timing, providing fiscal stimulus as a response to US President-elect Trump taxing US consumers of goods made in China is an obvious moment to choose. There's a weird symmetry. Trump taxing US consumers provides a convenient excuse for China to reduce taxes on China's consumers.
China's November export and import data was weaker than had been expected. One of the reasons to look for stimulus in China is the change in consumption patterns of developed economy consumers, which have favoured having fun over buying goods. That has in turn weakened China's export sector.
China's exports did rise in year-on-year terms, but it's worth remembering that China's calculation of its export numbers is unusual. China exports much more to the United States than the US imports from China, for example, and this discrepancy has emerged only in the past few years and is a growing trend. Falling imports into China underscores what needs to happen to support domestic demand, but it is worth recalling that China's consumers may be less willing to purchase imports in the wake of rising economic nationalism.
On the data calendar, there are final consumer price inflation numbers from Germany, but this is one of the few statistics that is rarely revised, so there's only very limited interest in this. US productivity and unit labour cost data for the third quarter are interesting in theory, but not terribly useful in practice. Productivity is whatever economists cannot explain, carefully branded to avoid giving the impression that economists do not know what they're talking about.
Unit labour costs rely on productivity in the calculation. We know labour costs have been moderated by the increased use of technology, not to mention getting people to work for free through things like self-service checkouts in stores. Finally, there is news that the pop artist Taylor Swift's Ere's Couture has generated around $2.1 billion in ticket sales.
Sources & References
How we cover this story