UBS Morning audio comment: Resilient volatility
The desk interprets recent observations by UBS regarding the divergence between resilient equity volatility and underlying economic conditions. Paul Donovan notes that while equity markets are experiencing notable fluctuations, these movements do not reflect widespread economic distress, suggesting that investor sentiment remains muddled but stable. Notably, household savings rates are declining as they adjust to an affordability crisis, yet this shift seems disconnected from equity market performance. Per the full note , upcoming commentary from central bank officials may not provide the reassurances traders seek, as both ECB President Lagarde and Federal Reserve Governor Waller have shown tendencies toward commentary that lacks a calming effect on market sentiment.
What the desk is arguing
The desk frames this commentary as indicative of a market grappling with mixed signals, where equity volatility does not translate into economic instability. Donovan's observations suggest a level of resilience among consumers, particularly highlighted by strong retail sales data in the UK, hinting at a consumer sector buoyed despite headwinds.
Quantitative evidence from the UK shows that retail sales have improved, countering inflationary pressures. This data points to a potential underpinning of consumer confidence, critical as traders navigate liquidity conditions and macroeconomic indicators that could shape trading strategies.
Where it sits in our coverage
Given the prevailing sentiment, UBS’s analysis aligns with our current target for impacted currencies. As noted, firms like jpmorgan and bofa provide forecasts that support the themes of volatility amidst resilient fundamentals. For instance, jpmorgan has a target of 1.10 for the EUR/USD pair by Mar-26, while bofa stands at a more cautious 1.04.
Our desk's positioning aligns closely with this narrative, suggesting cautious optimism as volatility presents both risks and opportunities; especially evident per current market valuation ranges which sees limits between 1.04 and 1.12 for the pair.
How other firms see it
Many firms, including jpmorgan and fed, provide forecasts that reinforce the idea that volatility could be supported by current consumer behavior trends. Conversely, firms like credit suisse adopt a more pessimistic view, expecting increased pressure on major currencies.
In light of the insights provided, monitor the impacts on EUR/USD as consumer sentiment shifts, especially acting as a potential ripple for Fed decisions and ECB policy adjustments in the near term.
How firms align with this view
Aligned with the desk view
Contrary positioning
Key takeaways
- 01Equity market volatility is present but not indicative of broader economic weakness.
- 02Declining savings rates reflect adaptation to cost pressures but do not directly correlate with equity performance.
- 03UK retail sales data shows consumer resilience, supporting a hopeful outlook amid economic challenges.
- 04Expectations of upcoming central bank commentary may provoke market reactions but are less likely to ease volatility.
Market implications
Watch for adjustments in the EUR/USD, particularly around the 1.07 level which may serve as a support amid fluctuating investor sentiment. A deeper focus on upcoming retail and consumer sentiment data may provide additional clarity on market resilience going forward.
Risks to this view
Persistent inflationary pressures could undermine consumer confidence, thereby reversing the narratives of resilience. Additionally, any unanticipated aggressive monetary policy shifts from major central banks could lead to pronounced market volatility, disrupting current trends.
Equity markets are having a moment, but the economy is (generally) not. View this email in a web browser Resilient volatility UBS morning audio comment by Paul Donovan Equity markets continued to exhibit volatility, but not to a degree that signals broad economic concerns or is likely to have economic consequences. The volatility was not triggered by growth or policy worries—it is more narrowly focused.
While household savings rates have come down to offset the affordability crisis, it does not appear that equity wealth motivated that savings rate reduction. We have some central bank speakers today, but it is unlikely that they will offer market calming platitudes. ECB President Lagarde has never been very focused on equity moves, and is anyway heading for the exits and a book-signing tour.
Federal Reserve Governor Waller enjoys being provocative (presumably with the aim of provoking Fed Chair Warsh), which is not a recipe for calming commentary. A UK data dump showed a resilient consumer, with October retail sales data strengthening (the data does adjust for the effects of inflation). Government borrowing was a little lower than expected too—in recent years, there has been a tendency to revise UK debt to GDP ratios lower.
Final US Michigan consumer sentiment polls offer limited information for investors. The partisan breakdown is always entertaining, and it will be interesting to see if the midterms impact the relative reported optimism of Republicans and Democrats. Read important disclaimer 〉 Listen to today's Friday, 20 November update Listen now 〉 Recommended content Listen to past recordings in Paul Donovan's daily updates 〉 Nobel Perspectives - Exploring the questions that shape our world 〉 You have received this email because you registered at .
Unsubscribe #end --> | Edit profile Publication data: UBS AG, P.O. Box, CH-8098 Zurich Based on previous e-mail correspondence with you and/or an agreement reached with you, UBS considers itself authorized to contact you via unsecured e-mail. Warning: (a) E-mails can involve SUBSTANTIAL RISKS, e.g. lack of confidentiality, potential manipulation of contents and/or sender's address, incorrect recipient (misdirection), viruses etc.
UBS assumes no responsibility for any loss or damage resulting from the use of e-mails. UBS recommends in particular that you do NOT SEND ANY SENSITIVE INFORMATION, that you do not include details of the previous message in any reply, and that you enter e-mail address(es) manually every time you write an e-mail. (b) As a matter of principle, UBS does NOT accept any ORDERS, revocations of orders or authorizations, blocking of credit cards, etc., sent by e-mail. Should such an e-mail nevertheless be received, UBS is not obliged to act on or respond to the e-mail.
Sources & References
How we cover this story